|Ability||End lineal afflictions by killing Troubled person|
|Appearance||Sins of the Fathers|
In June of 1981, Simon's Trouble was activated by Vince Teagues with Vince's own blood, after which Teagues persuaded Crocker to murder Teagues's father-in-law in order to protect Teagues's wife from her family's Trouble.
Like generations of Crockers before him, Simon hunted down Haven's afflicted in order to stop the troubles. He would often come home with wounds that Duke would have to clean up. Simon and his son didn't get along with each other, but when he was dying he told Duke to stay in Haven if the Troubles ever returned. Before he died, Simon made sure that Duke would get his boat, which contained his weapon box.
He later returned as a ghost to tell Duke about his legacy, instructing his son to kill Audrey Parker.
It is later found out through Vince, that he brought out Simon's Trouble and asked him to kill his father-in-law to end his wife's family Trouble. After this it was seen that Vince and Lucy killed Simon.
- "A Tale of Two Audreys" (mentioned)
- "Roots" (mentioned)
- "The Tides That Bind" (mentioned)
- "Sins of the Fathers" (ghost)
- "301" (mentioned)